PCMag's 2026 all-in-one printer guide: which to buy for home, office or photos
PCMag's tested list of printers that also scan, copy and fax picks winners by need, so you can skip the guesswork before you buy.
The short version
- Top laser pick: Brother MFC-L3780CDW. Top inkjet pick: Epson EcoTank ET-3950.
- PCMag says it has tested printers for four decades, using its own speed-testing method.
- Ink-tank models like the Canon Pixma G3270 trade speed for low running costs.
- Epson's XP-8800 and XP-980 target photo printing; the XP-980 prints borderless up to 11 by 17 inches.
- Brother's MFC-J5110DW is the pick for small offices needing an inkjet, with three trays.
Why it matters
A printer's sticker price is only part of what you pay, because ink, toner and replacement parts add up. A tested list that compares running costs, paper handling and scanning features helps you match a machine to how you actually work. It also keeps you from buying more printer than you need.
What PCMag published
As pcmag.com reported in its updated buying guide, a multifunction printer, also called an all-in-one or AIO, is a machine that prints and also scans and copies. Many models fax too. The guide says these devices range from compact units for homes and small offices to large floor-standing office machines.
The author says PCMag has tested printers for four decades. Each model is judged on speed, output quality, design and ease of use. Speed is measured with a formal testing method the author devised.
The headline picks are the Brother MFC-L3780CDW for a laser model and the Epson EcoTank ET-3950 for an inkjet. PCMag stresses that no single printer suits everyone, so the list is split by volume and budget.
Inkjet or laser, in plain terms
Inkjets spray liquid ink onto the page. Lasers use toner, a fine powder fused onto paper with heat. The guide covers both, and the trade-offs show up clearly in the picks.
The Epson ET-3950 is the inkjet to beat for a micro or home office, according to PCMag. It prints one-sided pages quickly, prints and scans two-sided pages automatically, and costs little to run. Its drawbacks are a single paper tray and a scanner that flips each page over rather than reading both sides in one pass.
The Canon Pixma G3270 is also a tank-based model with low running costs, even for color. It is slower, holds only 100 sheets, has no automatic document feeder (ADF, the tray that pulls in a stack of pages to scan), and needs you to flip pages by hand for two-sided printing. The included ink is rated for thousands of pages.
Picks for photos and small offices
For photo fans, PCMag lists two Epson models. The Expression Photo XP-8800 can scan, copy and print on discs, and it takes USB memory and SD cards. Its two paper trays and automatic two-sided printing help, but copies of photos look lackluster and there is no ADF.
The Expression Photo XP-980 prints borderless photos up to 11 by 17 inches. It adds an Ethernet connection, but it holds only one sheet of that large paper at a time.
For work, the Brother MFC-J5010DW is described as a good fit for busy small offices, with fast two-sided printing and a scanner that reads both sides in one pass. The MFC-J5110DW is PCMag's top inkjet for small offices or workgroups. It has three paper trays holding 600 pages in total and supports two printer languages common in offices. Both Brother inkjets cost more to run than tank-based rivals.
Laser options for busier workloads
The Brother MFC-L3780CDW is the budget color laser pick. It combines excellent print, copy and scan quality with competitive toner costs, plus a 50-page ADF that scans both sides in one pass and wireless options including NFC (tap-to-connect). Its multipurpose tray holds only 30 sheets.
The Xerox C305ae color laser has excellent document quality and a high monthly print volume rating, meaning it is built for heavy use. It has a 4.3-inch color touchscreen and accepts one or two optional extra paper trays. PCMag knocks it for weak printer-management software on a PC and for toner costs.
HP's Color LaserJet Enterprise MFP M480f is a mid-volume color laser with detailed printing, a small footprint and reasonable running costs. Its main downside is a somewhat high purchase price.
On the black-and-white side, the Brother MFC-L2900DW XL is a compact mono laser with a 250-sheet tray and a 50-sheet ADF. Its separate imaging unit is costly to replace. The guide also lists the four-function Brother MFC-L5915DW, though the text we have cuts off before its full description.
How to read the list
Start with what you do most. If you print occasionally and want low ink bills, the tank-based inkjets stand out. If you print photos, look at the Epson photo models. If you scan stacks of paperwork, check for an ADF that scans both sides in one pass.
Then check the downsides PCMag flags for each model, such as tray size, copy quality or replacement-part costs. Those are the details that usually decide whether a printer feels good a year later.
What to watch
- Whether PCMag updates the picks as new printers are tested during 2026.
- How running costs, such as ink, toner and imaging units, compare for the model you are considering.
Try it
Before shopping, write down how many pages you print a month and whether you scan stacks of paper. Then compare those needs with the pros and cons for each model in PCMag's guide.
Sources and links
- Reportingpcmag.com: the article we sourced
Read the original at pcmag.com
First reported by pcmag.com. Written by the SI Agent News Desk from the reporting above.Written with AI from the source above. Every number is checked against the source. Spot a mistake? Corrections.
Liked it? Say why
Add a line for other readers.
No account needed. We never show your email. Comments with links, ads or abuse are held and not shown. Your comment shows after a quick check.