We asked four AI tools for a Black Friday TV deal. Most links failed
The BBC asked ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini and Alexa to find a 55-inch TV bargain. Dead links and wrong prices show why you should check before you buy.
The short version
- The BBC's informal test asked four AI tools for a 55-inch TV deal, using free versions.
- ChatGPT's links to John Lewis and Richer Sounds led to a TV no longer listed online.
- Gemini's £539 price was right at Argos but £60 too low for Currys.
- Alexa's prices were all correct, but it only searches Amazon's own store.
- YouGov found 36% of Black Friday shoppers surveyed had no plan to use AI.
Why it matters
AI assistants can cut a huge list of offers down to a handful, but they can repeat old prices or point you to products you can't buy. Treat their answers as a starting list, not a verdict. A deal only counts if the price holds on the store's page.
The test: one TV, four assistants
Black Friday is built to overwhelm: endless offers, doubtful reviews, and "discounts" that may not be discounts. AI chatbots have been pitched as the fix. As the BBC reported, its team tried that claim a week before the sales, using the free versions of ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini and Amazon's Alexa.
The job was simple: find a good deal on a 55-inch television. The BBC says this was not a rigorous scientific experiment, and the results were mixed.
Where each assistant slipped
ChatGPT gave four options. Its top pick was a Hisense TV at Chinese retailer Joybuy, priced at £499 instead of £649. Another suggestion showed prices for a 50-inch model, not the 55-inch one. It also recommended the same Hisense at £649 from John Lewis and Richer Sounds as the safer buy, because of longer guarantees. Both stores said the set was no longer listed online. The last pick, an LG OLED at £1,100, was labelled as an ad.
Claude wrote the shortest answer and leaned on a small number of published reviews. Two of its links led to dead pages on the Richer Sounds site, and others went to round-ups of Black Friday 2025 deals. It also listed two Samsung sets only to say not to buy them, which left the testers puzzled.
Gemini produced a neat comparison table but no store links. One TCL price of £649 was right, though the set was sold out at one named retailer. A second TCL was quoted at £539 at Argos and Currys. That was correct for Argos, but Currys charged £60 more.
Alexa did best on accuracy. Its four TVs ranged from Amazon's own Ember at £532 to a £699 Samsung, and every price checked out. Its top pick was a Samsung at £616, down from £749. But one suggestion was only 50 inches, and Alexa searches just Amazon. It did tell the testers to look elsewhere, since prices vary and other shops may offer longer guarantees.
Few shoppers use AI, but tech firms are pushing
A YouGov survey across 19 countries put the UK second-last for the share of people who had used AI to help them shop. Among respondents planning to shop around Black Friday, 36% did not intend to use an AI tool at all. The survey did suggest more people are considering it.
Tech companies are moving in. Alexa for Shopping reached UK users this month. OpenAI released a Shopping Research tool in ChatGPT just before last year's Black Friday. In the US, Google has added Universal Cart, which includes price tracking and a feature that finds relevant promo codes.
Why live prices trip them up
Tech journalist Alex Hughes used ChatGPT's agent mode last year. An agent is AI that carries out several steps on its own. He wrote for Tom's Guide that the search took about 20 minutes with little effort from him. ChatGPT surfaced seven TVs. He later bought one of them, but found it cheaper in a physical shop. Asked if he would use AI for deals again, he told the BBC: "Probably not." He said live price data tends to come back inconsistent and often wrong.
Naureen Mohammed advises businesses on appearing in AI results. She says that if a retailer doesn't refresh its prices when bargain-hunting starts, old prices can be served up as today's deals. She also expects advertising to start shaping AI recommendations. Her analysis of UK chatbot answers on Black Friday tech found Amazon in half of responses, with Currys close behind. In short, big retailers dominate what you see.
Consumer group Which? makes a similar point. Senior researcher Hannah Walsh said that if a chatbot lists laptops under £400 and many cost more, you waste time sorting them. The reverse also happens: you can miss a good model because the bot overstated its price.
A sensible way to use them
The BBC's results don't say AI is useless. They say it works best as a first filter. Ask for a short list inside your budget, then check each pick yourself.
- Ask the assistant whether a price is this year's price.
- Click every link and confirm the price and stock on the store's own page.
- Check the screen size and model number match what you asked for.
- Compare at least one retailer the assistant didn't mention.
What to watch
- Will shopping tools like Universal Cart and Alexa for Shopping fix stale prices, or just move the problem?
- How much will ads and retailer tactics shape which products chatbots recommend?
Try it
Next time you shop, ask an AI for three options inside your budget. Then open each store page and check price, stock and screen size before trusting any of it.
Sources and links
- ReportingBBC: the article we sourced
First reported by BBC. Written by the SI Agent News Desk from the reporting above.Written with AI from the source above. Every number is checked against the source. Spot a mistake? Corrections.
Liked it? Say why
Add a line for other readers.
No account needed. We never show your email. Comments with links, ads or abuse are held and not shown. Your comment shows after a quick check.