Amazon and Perplexity AI fight over shopping assistant reaches lower court
A federal judge is weighing whether an AI tool that shops on Amazon violates computer fraud laws or simply follows user directions.
The short version
- Amazon claims Perplexity's Comet tool violates the U.S. Computer Fraud and Abuse Act.
- A Ninth Circuit appeals panel previously ruled that users, not the AI, are the ones accessing the site.
- Amazon argues a new version of Comet allows the tool to enter Amazon without a specific user invitation.
- Perplexity maintains that the AI only acts when a user provides direct instructions and account access.
Why it matters
This case will help define the legal boundaries for AI agents that perform actions on behalf of humans. The outcome could determine how much responsibility companies bear for the actions of the software they build.
The legal battle over AI agents
Amazon is currently engaged in a legal dispute with Perplexity AI regarding the functionality of a tool called Comet. This AI web browser is designed to help people shop on Amazon by comparing different prices and reading through customer reviews. Amazon argues that the way this tool operates violates existing laws, specifically the U.S. Computer Fraud and Abuse Act.
The core of the disagreement involves how the AI interacts with Amazon's systems. Amazon contends that the tool acts as an unauthorized entity that bypasses restrictions. They are seeking to stop the service, claiming it oversteps the boundaries of what is permitted for automated software to do on their platform.
As reported by Courthouse News, the case recently returned to a lower court after an appeals court intervened. The legal team for Amazon is trying to convince the judge that the AI's capabilities have evolved in a way that makes it a risk to their platform. They want the court to recognize the tool as a violation of their security protocols.
Conflicting views on user control
A previous ruling by a Ninth Circuit appeals panel sided with Perplexity. The panel suggested that the user is the one who actually "accesses" the computer systems because they are the ones giving the commands. Under this logic, the AI is simply a tool being used by a person, much like a web browser or a search engine.
Amazon's lawyers disagree with this interpretation and argue that the facts have changed. They claim that a newer version of Comet allows the AI to go to Amazon without being "invited in" by the user. They argue that if a user simply asks to buy an item, the tool initiates the connection independently, making Perplexity the "rogue actor" in control.
Perplexity's legal team maintains that the original ruling still holds true. They argue that the AI cannot access Amazon on its own and that a user must explicitly grant it access to their personal account. They characterize Amazon's current arguments as an attempt to find any possible reason to win the case as it faces potential dismissal.
Technical and legal hurdles
The court is currently grappling with how to apply the appeals court's specific instructions to the current facts. Judge Maxine Chesney expressed uncertainty about how to proceed given the conflicting arguments from both sides. She is trying to find a path forward that does not lead to another reversal by a higher court.
To manage the complexity of the case, the judge granted Perplexity's request for a stay in discovery. This means that the formal process of exchanging evidence and documents is paused for now. The stay is intended to keep costs down and provide the judge with more time to consider a motion to dismiss the case entirely.
The technical distinction between a tool that follows a command and a tool that acts autonomously is at the heart of the litigation. If the court finds that the AI acts without a specific invitation for every action, Amazon may have a stronger case for a violation of computer fraud laws. If the court finds it is always user-driven, Perplexity may prevail.
Impact on the AI landscape
This case is significant because it addresses the growing trend of AI agents performing real-world tasks. As companies develop tools that can book flights, buy groceries, or manage accounts, the question of liability becomes critical. The court must decide who is responsible when an AI performs an action that the platform owner considers unauthorized.
For consumers, the outcome could affect the availability of convenient shopping assistants. If Amazon wins, it might place heavy restrictions on how third-party AI tools can interact with its marketplace. This could limit the types of automated services that are available to people who want to use AI to simplify their online shopping.
For developers, the ruling will serve as a guide for building
What to watch
- Whether Judge Chesney grants a motion to dismiss the case.
- How the court defines 'authorized access' for AI agents.
- Whether new versions of Comet introduce more autonomous features.
Try it
Check your own AI settings to see if you have granted any third-party assistants permission to access your personal shopping or banking accounts.
Sources and links
Read the original at Courthouse News
First reported by Courthouse News. Written by the SI Agent News Desk from the reporting above.Written with AI from the source above. Every number is checked against the source. Spot a mistake? Corrections.
Liked it? Say why
Add a line for other readers.
No account needed. We never show your email. Comments with links, ads or abuse are held and not shown. Your comment shows after a quick check.