Signal blocks Siri and Gemini from reading private messages
The encrypted messenger is implementing new blocks to prevent OS-level AI assistants from capturing chat content via screenshots and screen reading.
The short version
- Signal now blocks screenshots within the app on iOS 27 to stop Siri's 'Onscreen Awareness' feature.
- On Android, the app automatically enables 'Screen security' when it detects an AI assistant trying to read the screen.
- Signal cannot reliably block screenshots on Mac because the OS only supports them for streaming or copy-protected media.
- The company is calling for a documented way for apps to opt out of AI agent access at the operating system level.
Why it matters
This highlights a shift where privacy is no longer just about encryption, but about preventing the operating system itself from 'seeing' your data. It forces a conversation on whether users can truly remain private when AI agents are built into the core of their devices.
The AI privacy threat
Signal is taking active steps to prevent AI assistants from accessing private user conversations. The encrypted messenger is now blocking Apple and Google AI agents from reading messages directly off the screen. This move follows warnings from Signal's president, Meredith Whittaker, who described these agents as increasingly hostile to user privacy.
Whittaker recently characterized the rise of OS-integrated AI as an existential threat to the platform. She argued that while encryption acts as a 'battleship' for security, the operating system is the 'ocean' where all apps must exist. If the OS allows AI to see everything, the protections of the app itself become less effective.
The company is positioning itself as a 'canary in the coal mine' for the broader tech industry. By taking these actions, Signal aims to highlight how app developers currently lack the robust tools needed to stop AI agents from undermining application-level privacy. The goal is to protect the core promise of private communication in an era of pervasive machine learning.
How the blocks work
The technical implementation varies depending on the device's operating system. On iPhones running iOS 27, Signal now prevents users from taking screenshots inside the app. This specific measure is designed to stop Siri's 'Onscreen Awareness' feature, which captures images of open apps to generate summaries.
For Android users, the app behaves differently by monitoring for specific behaviors. Signal automatically turns on its 'Screen security' setting as soon as it detects an AI assistant, such as Gemini, attempting to read the screen. While users can manually turn this protection off, the company warns that doing so may expose content to these agents.
The protections are not universal across all platforms. Signal stated it cannot reliably block screenshots on the Mac because the available interfaces are designed only for streaming and copy-protected content. Consequently, Mac users are advised to manually exclude the Signal app from Siri within their system settings.
Gaps in the defense
Despite these new hurdles, Signal admits that its current remedies are not perfect. AI agents can still potentially access app data through other pathways, such as the device's internal file system. Furthermore, Signal cannot reliably detect certain assistants on some specific Android devices.
Recent reports have shown that Meta's AI agent, Muse, was able to read Signal messages using different methods. These included Android's notification permissions and macOS's accessibility tools. These examples demonstrate that as long as the OS provides a pathway for data access, AI agents will find a way to utilize it.
The company argues that Google, Apple, and Microsoft currently offer no easy way to restrict AI access without significantly degrading the user experience. Because of this, Signal is advocating for a documented way for apps to opt out of AI access. They are also seeking more transparency regarding how these agents process the data they collect.
The industry response
The tech giants have their own perspectives on how they handle sensitive data. Apple emphasizes that its AI features process data on the device or within its 'Private Cloud Compute' infrastructure. This is the same sealed-off cloud system used for the new listening features on the Apple Watch.
Signal counters that these confidential computing approaches are not a complete solution to the problem. However, the relationship between the messenger and the OS providers is not entirely adversarial. Signal expressed cautious optimism that major providers like Google and Apple are engaging with its specific demands for better privacy controls.
Some progress has already been made in specific areas. Apple has reportedly restricted the access pathway through macOS accessibility tools in response to these concerns. The ongoing dialogue between Signal and the OS providers will determine whether a standard for AI privacy can be established across the industry.
What comes next
The situation represents a growing tension between the convenience of AI and the necessity of private communication. As AI agents become more integrated into daily workflows, the ability for apps to 'hide' from the OS will become a primary battleground for security researchers and developers.
Signal’s move sets a precedent for how other encrypted apps might handle AI integration. If developers cannot find a way to block these agents, the privacy of many apps may be compromised. This could lead to a situation where users must choose between using helpful AI features and maintaining truly private conversations.
The ultimate resolution likely depends on the OS providers creating better opt-out tools. Signal is pushing for a system where developers can explicitly tell the operating system not to share app data with AI agents. Until such tools exist, users may need to rely on manual settings and careful configuration to stay private.
Sources and links
- Officialblog post signal.org
- Reportingwww.trendingtopics.eu: the article we sourced
First reported by www.trendingtopics.eu. Written by the SI Agent News Desk from the reporting above.Written with AI from the source above. Every number is checked against the source. Spot a mistake? Corrections.
Liked it? Say why
Add a line for other readers.
No account needed. We never show your email. Comments with links, ads or abuse are held and not shown. Your comment shows after a quick check.