SI Agent News
DevelopingPolicy

New York City moves to ban AI-driven personalized pricing

The city council passed a bill to stop businesses from using personal data to charge different prices for the same goods or services.

Ink and watercolour: picture for the story 'New York City moves to ban AI-driven personalized pricing'
AI-made ink and watercolour for this story. No real people or products are shown.
250clients worked with by FTC intermediaries

The short version

Why it matters

This legislation addresses the growing concern that companies can use your private behavior to extract the maximum amount of money from you. It aims to create a more transparent marketplace where prices are not secretly tailored to your personal circumstances.

The end of secret pricing

The New York City Council recently passed a bill designed to crack down on a practice known as surveillance pricing. This specific type of pricing occurs when a business uses algorithms and personal data to determine what an individual person should pay for a specific item. Under the new rules, companies would be prohibited from charging different prices to different consumers for the exact same goods or services.

The legislation, identified as Introduction 891-A, targets the way businesses use your personal information to make commercial assessments. It aims to stop companies from calculating prices without the customer's knowledge based on their unique circumstances. If the bill becomes law, it will take effect one year after its official approval date.

The bill is currently awaiting action from the mayor before it can move forward. The primary goal of the measure is to address the lack of transparency in how companies assess consumer behavior. By limiting these practices, the city hopes to prevent customers from being charged more simply because a company knows they have fewer alternatives or an urgent need.

How surveillance pricing works

To understand the ban, it is important to distinguish surveillance pricing from standard dynamic pricing. Dynamic pricing typically responds to broad market conditions, such as a sudden spike in demand or a lack of available inventory. In contrast, surveillance pricing relies on specific personal information or consumer profiles to distinguish between individual shoppers.

Businesses may gather data points like your browsing history, your geographical location, and your past shopping habits. They can also look at demographic characteristics to estimate a person's willingness to pay for a product. This allows a company to identify which customers might be less sensitive to price increases and target them accordingly.

The Federal Trade Commission has already begun looking into these technologies. Their initial findings in January 2025 indicated that pricing tools could analyze very specific behaviors, such as how a user moves their mouse or which items they abandon in an online shopping cart. These technologies were being used by intermediaries working with at least 250 clients across various industries, including apparel and groceries.

Privacy and transparency risks

The push for this legislation stems from growing concerns about how extensive personal data collection affects privacy. Beyond just the cost of a product, these detailed consumer profiles can expose sensitive information. There is also a significant risk that this data could be disclosed to unauthorized parties without the consumer's consent.

Many consumers currently have very little understanding of how companies are actually assessing their behavior. Because these algorithms work behind the scenes, it is difficult for a shopper to know why they are seeing a specific price. The legislation seeks to fix this by limiting the use of personal data in pricing decisions, making the process more predictable for the average person.

It is important to note that personalized pricing does not always mean a customer will pay more. Some people might actually receive discounts based on their data profiles. However, the core issue remains the lack of clarity. The bill aims to ensure that businesses do not make individualized commercial assessments without clearly explaining those decisions to the public.

What stays the same

The proposed law is not intended to eliminate all types of price variations or discounts. It specifically targets the use of personal information for surveillance. For example, the bill would preserve certain legitimate discounts that are already common in the retail world. This includes qualifying loyalty and rewards programs that are clearly defined for all participants.

Discounts offered to specific, clearly defined groups will also remain permissible under the new rules. This includes price breaks for veterans, senior citizens, and teachers, provided they meet certain conditions. These exceptions are meant to distinguish established, fair discount arrangements from systems that rely on secret surveillance of individual consumers.

By focusing on the data used rather than the price itself, the law tries to strike a balance. It allows for traditional marketing and rewards while stopping the use of individual behavioral data to influence costs. If enacted, it will establish a new framework for how businesses operating in New York City can use consumer data when determining their final prices.

Next steps for the bill

Because the bill is currently awaiting action from the mayor, its final status is still pending. If it is signed into law, the city has provided a one-year grace period before the restrictions take effect. This timeline is intended to give affected businesses enough time to adjust their systems and data collection practices to comply with the new rules.

The legislation represents a significant step toward regulating how AI and data analytics are used in everyday commerce. It reflects a broader trend of looking at how personal information can be weaponized to influence consumer behavior. For residents of New York City, it could mean a more level playing field where prices are determined by market factors rather than personal profiles.

Moving forward, the focus will be on how the city defines the boundaries of 'personal information' in this context. Businesses will need to ensure that their pricing models do not rely on the sale or sharing of data intended to facilitate surveillance. The success of the bill will depend on how effectively it can stop these practices without hindering standard business operations.

What to watch

Try it

Check your recent online shopping history to see if you have received different prices for the same item when browsing from different devices or locations.

Sources and links

Liked it? Say why

Add a line for other readers.

No account needed. We never show your email. Comments with links, ads or abuse are held and not shown. Your comment shows after a quick check.

Listen to the AI Wire headlines

Listen to the AI Wire

Listen to our daily AI shows every morning: on your commute, in the shower, wherever you are

Listen to the daily shows

First reported by The 420.in · Read the original. Written by the SI Agent News Desk from the reporting above.Written with AI from the source above. Every number is checked against the source. Spot a mistake? Corrections.

More AI news