SI Agent News
DevelopingOpenAIAgentsPolicy

Italy fines Meta EUR805m over unauthorized access to photo galleries

The Italian regulator penalized Meta for allowing the Facebook app to read user photos and metadata without specific consent.

Documentary photo: picture for the story 'Italy fines Meta EUR805m over unauthorized access to photo galleries'
AI-made documentary photo for this story. No real people or products are shown.
EUR805mFine imposed on Meta by Italy

The short version

Why it matters

This ruling sets a high bar for how apps handle local device data, reinforcing the idea that access to a photo gallery is a private matter. It forces Meta to change its default settings and transparency standards for millions of users.

The privacy violation

Italy's data protection authority, the Garante, has issued a fine of EUR805 million against Meta. The penalty stems from the Facebook app's behavior on Android devices regarding how it interacts with user photo galleries. The regulator determined that the app was reading pictures, videos, and associated metadata to power a gallery suggestions feature.

This access was granted to approximately 20 million Android users in Italy. The Garante concluded that Meta failed to provide proper information or obtain specific consent before accessing this data. The investigation began in July 2025 following a report from a consumer group in Bolzano and lasted about 16 months.

The authority highlighted that the app used a single app-wide permission and a vague notice to justify the data collection. They ruled that these methods were insufficient to meet legal standards for user consent. The fine is calculated to be about 0.47% of Meta's total worldwide turnover.

Legal and regulatory hurdles

The Garante took the unusual step of refusing to hand the case over to Ireland's Data Protection Commission. Typically, the Irish commission leads cases against Meta in Europe, but the Italian authority argued that ePrivacy rules do not provide for a 'one-stop shop' mechanism in this instance. This means Italy chose to handle the enforcement independently based on specific local privacy codes.

The violation is governed by Article 122 of the Italian Privacy Code, which translates ePrivacy rules into requirements for accessing data stored on a device. The regulator framed the decision around the principle that a smartphone is part of a person's private sphere. They emphasized that data available on a device should not be used without explicit permission.

Several factors influenced the severity of the fine, including the scale of the violation and the duration of the non-compliance. The Garante also cited a previous 2019 enforcement action against the company and a lack of full cooperation as reasons to increase the penalty. Conversely, Meta's late changes following the initial complaint were considered a mitigating factor in the final ruling.

Mandatory remedies for Meta

Meta is now required to implement several specific changes to how it handles photo access. The company must ask for separate, specific consent rather than relying on broad app permissions. Additionally, the gallery suggestions feature must be switched off by default, even for users who had previously granted the system permission.

The regulator has established a strict reporting timeline for these changes. Meta must report back to the authority after one, two, and three months of implementation. If the company misses the two-month deadline, the feature will be prohibited from being switched on for anyone without valid consent.

While the investigation did not examine whether gallery content was used to train AI, Meta has denied such claims. However, the regulator noted that a newer gallery feature which processes images in the cloud will be assessed in a separate proceeding. This distinction highlights the different regulatory paths for local data versus cloud-processed data.

Technical responses from browsers

The privacy concerns surrounding Meta's photo handling prompted a technical response from the Brave browser. Brave recently updated its desktop version to strip hidden identifiers that Meta stamps on photos shared via Facebook and Instagram. These identifiers appear in the IPTC 'Special Instructions' field of image metadata.

When a user downloads a photo, Brave now deletes the string beginning with 'FBMD' before the file is saved. If a user uploads a photo, the browser sends a cleaned copy to the platform while leaving the original file on the user's device untouched. Brave stated that Meta has not disclosed the purpose or the reason for adding this identifier.

The browser's concern is that these identifiers might stay the same even if a second user re-uploads the same photo. This could potentially allow Meta to link the same image across different accounts or websites. Brave noted that the request to address this metadata issue had remained open for more than seven years before being closed in October 2026.

The shift toward agentic commerce

While regulators are tightening data access, OpenAI is moving toward a different model of permission for AI agents. On November 13, the company introduced a way for its AI agents to make payments without ever seeing a user's real card number. This system allows agents to buy items online while requiring a manual check, such as a fingerprint or Face ID, for every purchase.

The ChatGPT Wallet was built in partnership with American Express, Mastercard, and Visa. It is currently limited to US ChatGPT Pro subscribers who are at least 18 years old and have eligible US-issued cards. OpenAI described this as a way to let agents pay without granting them access to sensitive financial details.

To support this, OpenAI released a Commerce Partner Playbook for merchants. The document instructs websites to ensure that their bot defenses do not inadvertently block signed requests from these agents. This move aims to accommodate the 1.2 billion weekly users of ChatGPT, making it easier for AI to interact with the broader economy while maintaining security boundaries.

What to watch

Sources and links

Liked it? Say why

Add a line for other readers.

No account needed. We never show your email. Comments with links, ads or abuse are held and not shown. Your comment shows after a quick check.

Listen to the AI Wire headlines

Listen to the AI Wire

Listen to our daily AI shows every morning: on your commute, in the shower, wherever you are

Listen to the daily shows

First reported by PPC Land · Read the original. Written by the SI Agent News Desk from the reporting above.Written with AI from the source above. Every number is checked against the source. Spot a mistake? Corrections.

More AI news