Ask four AI assistants about Vienna's Christmas markets and you get four stories
A Vienna study of 262 questions found AI answers on Christmas markets shaky, dated and sometimes wrong. The lesson reaches well beyond mulled wine.
The short version
- WU Vienna and ainomics tested four assistants over three weeks with 262 questions.
- 31% of answers cited outdated web pages from 2023 to 2025.
- 54% of answers did not draw on the markets' official websites.
- Copilot briefly cancelled the Belvedere market based on a wrong blog post.
- The Rathausplatz market was named most often; small district markets barely appeared.
Why it matters
People increasingly use chatbots for travel and event planning, and this study shows how unstable those answers can be. For anything with a date, a price or an address, the official source still has to be the final check. For businesses, it also shows that what AI says about you depends on what is published about you online.
What the researchers did
Researchers at the Vienna University of Economics and Business (WU) and a Vienna AI consultancy called ainomics asked four AI assistants about the city's Christmas markets. The assistants were ChatGPT, Copilot, Google AI Overviews (the AI-written summaries at the top of Google results) and Perplexity. The test ran for three weeks and used 262 questions, as Kurier reported.
The overall finding was blunt. Answers were inconsistent, partly out of date and sometimes simply wrong. The study compares asking an AI once to drawing a card: the same question can bring a different answer the next day, or from a different assistant.
The market that vanished
The most vivid example involves the market at the Belvedere, a palace in Vienna. Copilot said the market was cancelled, and it based that claim on a blog post that turned out to be wrong.
Copilot later corrected itself, but the fix did not fully work. The next day the Belvedere market was missing from its list altogether. A correction that makes an event disappear is arguably worse than the original mistake, because nothing signals that anything is wrong.
Where the answers come from
The study also looked at which sources the assistants used. Some 31% of answers cited web pages from 2023 to 2025, so they could describe a past season rather than this one. More than half of the answers, 54%, did not rely on the markets' official websites.
One reason is that those sites often say little about practical questions such as prices, the deposit on mugs (the Häferlpfand) or whether you can pay by card. The assistants fill that gap with private guides, forums, social media and press coverage. The result is that mulled-wine prices were often wrong. Asked which market sells the cheapest mulled wine, Copilot gave very different answers on different days.
Favorites, blind spots and the press
- Favorites by theme: Spittelberg for romance, Karlsplatz for crafts, Freyung for tradition and Schönbrunn for families.
- Most mentioned: the Rathausplatz, which all four assistants also treated as the most touristy.
- Nearly invisible: markets outside the center and small district markets. Türkenschanzpark at least made the lists as an insider tip.
Language mattered too. Tourists asking in English and locals asking in German received different answers.
News coverage shaped a lot of this. The share of news sources among the citations rose steadily before the season began, and for each market the most-cited news article tended to set the tone of what the AI said about it. A press release from the City of Vienna was cited in 19% of all AI answers just one day after it was published, which shows how quickly a single document can steer what the assistants say.
What it means for you and for businesses
Thomas Reutterer, a marketing professor at WU, called the study a textbook case of what changes as AI-based search spreads. His advice to companies is to think about how to stay visible in these new channels. For consumers, he suggests being deliberate about the search terms you enter and putting the same question to several systems to get a broader picture.
The practical takeaway is simple. A chatbot can help you draft a shortlist, but opening dates, prices and cancellations belong to the organizer, and the organizer's own page is the place to confirm them. The study also hints at a quieter issue: if a small market is rarely mentioned online, the assistants may act as though it does not exist.
That matters for any seasonal business, tour or stall. When an official site is silent on a question, an AI will answer it anyway, using whatever it can find elsewhere.
What to watch
- Whether the assistants start giving more consistent answers as official sources publish practical details.
- Whether event organizers add prices, deposits and payment options to their websites so AI has better material to quote.
Try it
Ask two different assistants the same question about a local event or opening hours, compare the answers, then check the organizer's own website. If you run a small business, search for yourself the same way.
Sources and links
- ReportingKurier: the article we sourced
First reported by Kurier. Written by the SI Agent News Desk from the reporting above.Written with AI from the source above. Every number is checked against the source. Spot a mistake? Corrections.
Liked it? Say why
Add a line for other readers.
No account needed. We never show your email. Comments with links, ads or abuse are held and not shown. Your comment shows after a quick check.