Analysts warn China may answer tighter US chip rules with rare earth curbs
Analysts say Beijing could hit back with rare earth export limits if Washington tightens chip rules, though others expect little effect on trade talks.
The short version
- Victor Gao of the CCG think tank says Beijing would tighten rare earth export controls if the US pressed harder on chips.
- Wang Yingliang says China could also sanction US firms and trade on rare earths, narcotics and telecom fraud cooperation.
- Wang adds that China holds substantial chip inventories and is improving its own technology, so it can absorb a short-term hit.
- Trump and Xi are due to meet at APEC in Shenzhen on Nov. 18-19.
- Nothing in the report says any new US rule or Chinese measure is scheduled.
Why it matters
Chip rules and mineral supply are being discussed as linked levers, and rare earths go into a wide range of hardware, not just AI. If either side acts, the effects could reach prices and lead times well beyond the chip industry. For now, this is analyst opinion, so the useful move is to watch for actual rule text.
The warning from Beijing's side
As Seoul Economic Daily reported, citing the South China Morning Post, analysts say China could answer tighter US semiconductor export limits by restricting rare earths. Rare earths are a group of minerals that go into many kinds of electronics and machinery, and China has leaned on them before as a pressure point.
The trigger in this scenario is the exit of Jensen Huang, whom the report describes as Nvidia's former chief executive. We have not seen that description confirmed elsewhere in today's coverage, so treat it as the report's framing. The worry is that Washington might use the episode as an opening to squeeze China's access to advanced AI chips.
Victor Gao, a vice president at the Center for China and Globalization, a Chinese think tank, said such a move would be "a complete miscalculation". He added that Beijing would respond by tightening its own rare earth export controls.
A scandal that became a security issue
Wang Yingliang, editor-in-chief of the analysis platform Sharp Voices, said the controversy over Huang's extramarital affair has grown into a national security matter. In his view, that hands the US a fresh justification for tougher chip controls.
An investigation is also continuing into allegations that Alice Huang, named as the woman involved with the former CEO, spied for China. Analysts called this a wild card. These are allegations under investigation, not established facts.
Wang expects President Trump to keep the current chip export policy unless the security controversy spreads further. In other words, the tightening that analysts are warning about is not the base case in his reading.
China's other options, and why some shrug
Wang laid out what Beijing could do besides curbing minerals. It could sanction American companies. It could also offer or withhold help on rare earth exports, narcotics and telecom fraud, treating them as chips in a negotiation, with the aim of winning looser US chip limits.
But he also argued the stakes for talks are lower than they look. China, he said, has built up substantial chip inventories and is improving its own technology, which gives it room to take a short-term hit from new sanctions. His conclusion was that semiconductors will not weigh heavily on the trade negotiations.
So the analysts quoted here disagree on tone. One predicts a sharp counterstrike if rules tighten; another says China can ride it out and the talks will mostly carry on.
A shakier backdrop for the talks
Some analysts say US-China relations are less stable than before. Xu Tianchen of the Economist Intelligence Unit, a British research firm, said the "constructive strategic stability" the two leaders agreed earlier is a matter between China and Trump, and that Trump has been weakened. The report ties that view to the Democratic Party's sweeping win in the recent US midterm elections.
The next test comes soon. Trump and Chinese President Xi Jinping are expected to meet on the sidelines of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation leaders' gathering in Shenzhen, in Guangdong province, on Nov. 18-19. It would be their third meeting this year. Chips and rare earths are shaping up as the main points of friction.
The pattern so far is simple. Washington has limited sales of advanced chips to China since Trump took office, and Beijing's main counter has been rare earth export controls. The two sides have kept a temporary truce through trade talks, but a new chip restriction could break it.
Beyond politics: the chip race itself
The report also cites China's state-run Global Times, which carried analysts' views on what Huang's departure means for the industry. Liu Shaoshan, of the Shenzhen Institute of Artificial Intelligence and Robotics for Society, expects big technology companies to speed up their own chip design and spread their bets across different computing architectures.
He said the AI industry is moving from training large language models toward inference (running finished models for users), robotics and other real-world services. In that world, he argued, competition will turn on more than raw computing power, including software ecosystems and application costs.
Liu credited Huang with building both the GPUs (graphics processors widely used for AI) and the CUDA software platform around them. He said Nvidia's edge will not vanish quickly, but that Huang's leadership and ability to rally the industry will be hard to replace.
What to watch
- Whether Washington publishes any new chip export rule, or Beijing any new rare earth measure, before or after the Nov. 18-19 meeting.
- Whether the investigation into the spying allegations spreads and turns the story into a wider security dispute.
- Whether China's chip stockpiles and home-grown technology prove enough to absorb a tougher US stance.
Try it
When you read about chip or mineral restrictions, look for actual rule text from either government. Treat analyst forecasts like this one as scenarios, not scheduled events.
Sources and links
Liked it? Say why
Add a line for other readers.
No account needed. We never show your email. Comments with links, ads or abuse are held and not shown. Your comment shows after a quick check.
Listen to the AI Wire headlines
Listen to the AI WireListen to our daily AI shows every morning: on your commute, in the shower, wherever you are
Listen to the daily showsFirst reported by Seoul Economic Daily · Read the original. Written by the SI Agent News Desk from the reporting above.Written with AI from the source above. Every number is checked against the source. Spot a mistake? Corrections.
