SIAgentNews.com
← All news

A longtime Claude Code user switches to Pi, a little-known open-source coding tool

An engineer who used Claude Code for years left over a pile of small annoyances, a reminder that people pick tools for fit, not feature counts.

· First reported by kn.itmedia.co.jp

The short version

  • Caleb used Claude Code from the time it came with the Claude Pro plan, then moved to Pi.
  • Pi is open-source and works with models from Anthropic, OpenAI and Google.
  • His complaints: duplicate instruction files, limited VS Code integration, feature creep and changing hidden prompts.
  • He says the first days on Pi needed tuning, and he built a missing feature as an extension himself.

Why it matters

Churn in coding tools may come less from model quality than from daily friction and tools that grow more complicated. If you choose a coding assistant for yourself or a team, test it on your own routine rather than trusting popularity or a long feature list.

A loyal user walks away

As kn.itmedia.co.jp reported, a software engineer named Caleb decided to leave Claude Code, Anthropic's AI coding tool, after using it for years. It does more than write code: it edits files and runs commands on a developer's computer.

He began using it when it became available through the Claude Pro subscription, and he still credits it as a pioneer. He explained his move to a little-known tool called Pi in a blog post titled "Goodbye Claude, Hello Pi."

What Pi is

Pi is an open-source tool, meaning its code is public. It is not an AI model like Claude. It is a harness, the layer that lets a model create files, edit them and run commands.

It keeps its core simple and lets users add extensions and prompt templates to fit their own routine. It works with models from Anthropic, OpenAI and Google, so users can choose the model per task.

Small frictions that added up

Caleb's complaints were practical. Claude Code reads project rules from a file called CLAUDE.md, while other tools use AGENTS.md, so he had to duplicate content or link the two. Claude Code announced AGENTS.md support the day after he decided to switch, which he felt was too late.

He also disliked the VS Code integration. One connection method allowed only one session at a time, and the graphical extension lacked some built-in commands. With several sub-agents (helper AIs working in parallel) running, their output was mixed into one conversation, which he found hard to follow.

  • New features such as dynamic workflows, agent teams and Ultrareviews were not needed in his work.
  • Hidden instructions change often, which can clash with a user's own rules.
  • The description of the Bash tool alone took about three thousand tokens (the small units AI models count text in), much of it explaining Git, which he argues the model already knows.

Life on Pi, and the caveat

Caleb says the first few days on Pi needed adjustment, then it became comfortable. He praises its stability, simple design and flexibility. A feature he missed, sharing code selected across several tabs, took him about twenty minutes to build as an extension.

Freedom has a cost, though. Tuning your own setup takes effort, and the source notes that switching does not guarantee a better experience for everyone. This is one engineer's account, not a measure of how many people are leaving.

What to watch

  • Will Anthropic trim features or simplify its hidden instructions in response to complaints like these?
  • Do more developers move to open-source harnesses that let them pick the AI model?

Try it

Pick one real task you do often and run it in two coding assistants. Note which one needs fewer workarounds, not which has more features.

Sources and links

First reported by kn.itmedia.co.jp. Written by the SI Agent News Desk from the reporting above.Written with AI from the source above. Every number is checked against the source. Spot a mistake? Corrections.

Liked it? Say why

Add a line for other readers.

No account needed. We never show your email. Comments with links, ads or abuse are held and not shown. Your comment shows after a quick check.

More AI news